Keywords
reform
Punjab
small farmers
contract farming
How to Cite
Abstract
Agricultural markets are key to ensuring higher farmer incomes, but in India, agricultural market reforms have been stuck for almost two decades as agriculture is a state subject. The Union Ministry of Agriculture and Farmer Welfare (MoAFW) framed two new Acts on agricultural produce wholesale markets and contract farming (besides amending the Essential Commodities Act, 1955) in 2020 to allow and encourage new market channels in terms of buying from or working directly with farmers. These were parallel to state governments changing their APMC Acts, following the Model APMC Acts suggested by the Union MoAFW. This paper assesses the rationale and benefits of the 2020 Acts, and their implications for farmers and other stakeholders. It also examines the major provisions of the new Acts, i.e. APMC mandi bypass Act, 2020, which creates a new trade area outside the purview of the APMCs, and the Contract Farming Act, 2020, besides the amendments to these Union Acts by the state government of Punjab (2020), as informed by research studies on various marketing channels used by farmers and their experience of the same. The paper highlights some major lacunae of the 2020 Acts, in the context of Punjab agriculture, and examines the utility of the Punjab’s amendments to the Central Acts. The paper highlights the need for legal provisions to protect smallholder interests and leverage new channels for their development.References
Arora, S (2020): By amending Model Mandi Act, MP has pushed its agricultural sector into throes of uncertainty, Indian Express, December 21.
Bera, S (2021): What trade freedom did to Bihar farmers, Mint, March 8, p.8, Ahmedabad.
Dwary, A (2021): Madhya Pradesh Mandis' Revenue at One-Third in January, To Rent Out Space, NDTV. Com, Feb. 12.
FAO and IISD (2018): Model agreement for responsible contract farming, with commentary, FAO, Rome.
GoP (2020): The farmers’ produce trade and commerce, (promotion and facilitation) (special provisions and Punjab Amendment) Bill, 2020, Punjab Vidhan Sabha Bill No. 32-PLA-2020, Government of Punjab (GoP).
GoP (2020a): The farmers (empowerment and protection) agreement on price assurance and farm services (special provisions and Punjab Amendment) Bill, 2020, Punjab Vidhan Sabha Bill No. 33-PLA-2020, Government of Punjab (GoP).
Gupta, P, R Khera, and S Narayanan (2020):MSP- the factoids versus the facts, The Hindu, December 19.
Kakvi, K (2020): New las paralyse 70% of MP’s Mandis in six months, News Click, December 7.
Kumar, P (2006): “Contract Farming through Agribusiness Firms and State Corporation: A Case Study in Punjab,” Economic & Political Weekly, 41, (52), 5367–75.
Kaur P and N Singla (2018): Can Contract Farming Double Farmers’ Income? Economic & Political Weekly, 53(51), Dec 29.
MPSAMB (2005): M P Krishi Upaj Mandi Adhiniyam, 1972 (MP Act No. 24 of 1973), up-to- date amended Act, MPSAMB, Bhopal.
MoAFW (2020): The Farmers Produce Trade and Commerce (promotion and facilitation) Bill, No. 10 of 2020.
MoAFW (2020a): The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement on Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill, No. 11 of 2020.
Narayanan, S (2020):The Three Farm Bills, The India Forum, October 2.
Shah, M (2021): Mere Paas Sarkaar Hai, The India Forum, February 5.
Siddique, I (2020): Amid new farm laws, pandemic, Madhya Pradesh mandis take a hit, Indian Express, December 14.
Singh, M P (2007): Contract Farming and Emerging Agrarian Structure: The Case of Punjab, Ph D thesis, New Delhi, CSRD, JNU.
Singh, S (2002): “Contracting Out Solutions: Political Economy of Contract Farming in the Indian Punjab,” World Development, 30(9),1621–38.
Singh, S (2005): “Role of the state in contract farming in Thailand: Experience and Lessons”, ASEAN Economic Bulletin, 22(2), 217-228. (now Journal of Southeast Asian Economies from 2013).
Singh, S (2008): Marketing channels and their implications for smallholder farmers in India, in McCullough, E.B., Pingali, P.L. and Stamoulis, K.G (eds.): The Transformation of Agri-food Systems: Globalization, Supply Chains, and Smallholder Farmers, , Rome and London, FAO and Earthscan Press , 279-310.
Singh, S (2009): “Supply Chains for High Value Crops: A Case Study of Mint in Punjab,” Indian Journal of Agricultural Marketing, 23(1), 93–102.
Singh, S (2011): Contract farming for sustainable agricultural development in India: A smallholder perspective, IGIDR Proceedings of workshop on policy options and investment priorities for accelerating agricultural productivity and development in India, held at IIC, New Delhi, Nov 10-11.
Singh, S (2012): New Markets for Smallholders in India: Exclusion, Policy and Mechanisms, Economic & Political Weekly, 47 (52), 95-105, December 29.
Singh, S (2013): Regulating contract farming — Punjab way, The Tribune, Chandigarh, July 8. Op ed Agriculture page.
Singh, S (2015): “Reforming markets, lessons from Bihar, The Tribune, Chandigarh, Feb. 6, Op ed. Agriculture, page 9.
Singh, S (2020): Farm Laws: Design leaves much to be desired, Ideas for India, October 13.
Singh, S (2020a): New investment needs incentives, not only ease of doing business, Times of India, October 21.
Singh, S (2020b): The (food)grain of Punjab’s own farm Bills, Business Standard, October 21.
Singh, S (2020c): Amending agri market law but half-heartedly, The Tribune, Feb 17.
Singh, S (2020d): Can Cong states’ amended Acts help farmers?, The Hindu Business Line, opinion, Nov. 11.
Singh, S (2020e): Farmers’ freedom at stake, Frontline, October 23, 27-31.
Singh, S (2020): A Bill to Corporatise Agriculture, Frontline, 97-98, June 5,
Singh, S (2021): Middleman’s role, Frontline, January 1.
Singh, S (2021a): Separating grain from the chaff, The Pioneer, February 5, p. 7.
Singh, S and T Singh (2014): Producer companies in India: Organisation and performance, New Delhi, Allied Publishers.
Singh, S (2021): Understanding Performance and Impact of Producer Companies: Case Studies across States and Promoters in India, Final Report for MoAFW, CMA, IIM, Ahmedabad.
Sinha, S (2020): The agrarian crisis in Punjab and the making of the anti-farm law protests, The India Forum, December 4.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Copyright (c) 2024 Sukhpal Singh